100% Satisfaction Guarantee
Call Us
September 14, 2019

Guide: Baseball Trading Pins and Why They Are Cool

September 14, 2019
Baseball trading pins are one of the coolest things a baseball fanatic can own or trade. Here's a guide on why they are so cool, and where to get them.

Baseball is a beloved past time for many sports enthusiasts of all ages. It allows friends and family to gather for the sake of doing something fun. And, whether you enjoy watching the sport or you're always on the field, there is added pleasure in collecting baseball trading pins.

But, why are baseball pins so cool, you ask? We'll go into it with greater detail in a moment. For the time being, remember that being cool is all about being a good sport.

Baseball pins invoke camaraderie and team effort. They're also a good way to show off your team spirit. No matter how cool you want to be, starting a baseball trading pins collection is a good place to start.

If you're trying to learn more about why these little pins are so cool, you've come to the right place. In this article, we're providing you a little history and details to get you started on the coolest collection in town.

About Baseball Trading Pins

Baseball pins got their start in an unusual place back in the 1920s and 1930s. It was a Bakery in Rochester, NY, that started the tradition of trading pinback buttons that featured famous baseball players. Patrons received a pin with their favorite hometown heroes displayed with each loaf of bread purchased from the bakery.

The pins came in sets that were made in 1920, 1922, and 1933.

That's part of the excitement of collecting - you just might end up with one of these originals in your own collection someday!


Baseball itself is a timeless tradition that has roots as far back as the 1300s in France. Today, it's regarded as America's favorite sport after earning a rich history in the United States.

With baseball gaining in popularity around the turn of the 20th century, it became a profitable market for manufacturers and retail sellers. People that love baseball will inevitably buy baseball related products and collectibles. And so, baseball collector's pins got their start.


Remember those original pins that started with the Bakery almost a hundred years ago? Those pins are worth some big bucks nowadays because they are rare and hard to find. There are other pins that have been popular through the years and thus carry a high value.

Your favorite pin is also your most valuable pin when it comes to trading time. And, you may even be keeping it because you think it could be worth some money someday.

If you become a serious collector, you could find some valuable pins along the way.

Why Trading Pins are So Cool

Besides the value and history of your favorite trading pins, they're so cool because they allow you to show off your pride in and for baseball. It's an awesome way to decorate your favorite hat or backpack. Get them in all the different styles to add variety to your collection.

There are four different styles of baseball pins to choose from:

  • Soft Enamel Pins: Longer lasting. Most beginners start their collections with soft enamel pins because they are generally most affordable.
  • Offset Printed Pins: Printing your art onto vinyl layer on top of iron sheet metal. These pins are colorful and sturdy.
  • Quick Pins: Basic pins with a predetermined design.

Where to Get More Trading Pins

Now that you know how cool baseball pins really are, it's time to start your own collection. Even if you already have a collection going, you need to know where to get more pins and trade them, too.


Of course, you'll already be at your favorite teams' baseball games or your own where other collectors are bound to hang out. Maybe you know some people on your own team, or even the opposing team, that collects pins. If you don't, ask around.

Asking around is a great way to get others to start collecting, too. This way, you'll have more people to trade with later on.

Trading Events

Ask around some more or look for local postings where 'pinheads', or other pin collectors meet up and talk about their pins and even trade with others.

You can start up your own trading events with friends and collectors that you meet. It won't be hard to start up a conversation about your pins if you wear them often. And, other collectors will be able to find you in a crowd.


There are many collectors that trade pins via online forums and auctions. You can find local and international websites dedicated to helping collectors find the pins they're looking for.

Don't forget to work your social media channels, too. Social media networks are extremely expansive so that you may reach even more collectors.

Local Sports Shops

Local sports shops are best known for carrying your favorite sports memorabilia. So, make sure to ask them if people are looking for baseball pins. Maybe the shop even has a few that you're looking for.

Sports shops are great places to meet other fans and even if the shop doesn't have pins, there might be other collectors hanging out there anyway.

Trading Pins Are Fun to Collect

Whether you're trying to be the coolest collector in town or you just really love baseball, trading pins are fun to collect any time of the year. All you have to do is figure out what kind you like and get out there and find them. You'll be the talk of the team when you introduce others to this awesome past time.

Anything that is this fun is bound to be cool by most standards. It gives you a reason to connect with your friends and make new ones. And, of course, if you're lucky enough to find a gem, you could even make some money down the line.

If you're interested in trading pins, or if you have questions, contact us! Or, you can get a quote to jumpstart your collection, today.

Sign up to our newsletter

Get the latest articles on our news and promo discount delivered straight to your inbox

Ready to customize your pin?

Get Started

Related Posts

The Filthiest Pitches in Baseball

There are many different factors that go into creating the perfect pitcher. In fact, creating the perfect pitcher is probably not possible. Having said that, it is possible for a guy to hone his skills and create a perfect pitch. There have been many pitchers who have gone entire decades dominating the entire league, and […]
Read this post

Teams We'Ve Worked With


Want to learn more about Baseball Trading Pins? We are always writing interesting articles about everything challenge coins! Browse our coin blog.

Baseball Trading Pins Guide

Read More

Baseball Trading Pins Guide

Read More

Baseball Trading Pins Guide

Read More
View All Resources

Limited Edition Pins Gallery

View Gallery
Back to Top