100% Satisfaction Guarantee
Call Us
September 4, 2018

The 5 Rarest and Most Valuable Baseball Trading Pins

September 4, 2018
Finding rare and valuable baseball trading pins is exciting! Pin traders are always on the lookout for these collectibles. Here are the five most valuable pins every pinhead would love to own.

Are you an obsessive collector of baseball pins?

Or perhaps you're just starting to build your own collection, and want to know more about what you should look out for.

If this sounds like you, then you need to keep on reading. In this post, we'll tell you everything you need to know about five of the most valuable baseball trading pins of all time.

We'll even let you know where you can find press pins and rare Copperstown pins for your favorite baseball player or fan!

1. The Jackie Robison Rookie Pin

valuable baseball trading pins

One of the most valuable baseball trading pins of all time also serves as a reminder of the importance of diversity and inclusion.

On the fifteenth of April in 1947, famed baseball player Jackie Robison played his first ever game with the Brooklyn Dodgers. He was the first ever black player to ever step on the field of a major league baseball game.

He was only 28 years old.

He weathered torrents of abuse and racial slurs while on the field, but was still named the Rookie of the Year, and then became the Most Valuable Player in 1949.

He would later command the highest salary of any of the other players on the Dodgers team.

He retired in 1956.

Getting your hands on Jackie's Rookie Pin from 1947 is difficult -- making it one of the most valuable pins out there today.

In general, you can expect to pay anywhere from $1,500 and up for this pin.

2. A 1912 Press Pin

valuable baseball trading pins

If you're interested in press pins, then it's likely that you already know about the legendary 1912 press pin.

There are lots of different things that make this pin as special as it is.

First of all, 1912 was the year that Fenway Park came into existence.

Additionally, the Boston Red Sox and the Giants faced off in a Word Series that any true baseball fan wishes they'd been able to see. In the bottom of the tenth, the Red Sox were able to come back for an incredible win.

This epic victory makes this pin especially coveted by die-hard Boston Red Sox fans, as a reminder of what their team is capable of doing.

But unless you have some pretty deep pockets, be prepared to admire this pin from afar. In fact, it's so valuable, that the pin has sold for close to $60,000 at auctions in the past.

3. Lou Gehrig's 1933 Cracker Jack Prize

valuable baseball trading pins

Especially if you have young children, it's difficult to imagine attending a baseball game that doesn't include everyone's favorite snack -- Cracker Jacks.

Cracker Jacks often included specialized collector's pins in their famous snack boxes. One of the most popular was Lou Gehrig's pin.

Though these pins aren't always in the best of shape when they come up for auction (after all, they were included as a prize inside of a snack box!) they're still one of the most valuable baseball trading pins.

This is due in no small part to the tragic passing of Lou Gehrig from ALS.

Another one of the most popular baseball pins that also honors Lou Gehrig?

His Memorial Pin, which was created in 1941, the same year that he sadly lost his battle with ALS.

4. Topps Pins From 1956

valuable baseball trading pins

Topps has long been heralded as one of the most successful baseball trading card companies of all time.

An aspect of the company's history that most people aren't aware of, however?

The fact that in the year 1956, the company actually stopped making their cards. Instead, they decided to see what would happen if they focused on making pins.

They made a total of 60 pins. Some of the most popular players included Jackie Robison and Willie Mayes.

While you could buy them for only about 5 cents in 1956, good luck being able to pay that low of a price for these pins today!

The entire set of 60 pins has been known to sell for well over ten thousand dollars.

After all, since 11 of the players on the pins later became Hall of Fame members, it's not hard to see why!

5. A 1927 Press Pin

valuable baseball trading pins

In this final entry on our list of the most valuable baseball pins comes one of the most coveted World Series Pins.

In this series, the New York Yankees took on the Pittsburg Pirates -- and the fame didn't exactly fall in the Pirates' favor.

In fact, the Yankees were able to completely sweep the Pirates, 4 to 0. This was the first ever sweep that an American League team made over a national one -- so it's certainly cemented in baseball history.

Another aspect of the game that makes this pin so popular?

Baseball legends Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth both played in this game.

In the past, this pin has fetched prices that come close to $6,000 -- so, it's certainly worth saving up for!

Want to Learn More about the Valuable Baseball Trading Pins?

We hope that this post has helped to better educate you about five of the most valuable baseball trading pins on the market today.

Of course, we know that for true fans, the price point isn't really what matters. Instead, what's important is the history behind these iconic baseball pins.

Are you interested in adding to your current collection of baseball trading pins? Maybe you'd like to gift a few pins to your Little League Player?

Whatever the case, we're here to help you find the pins you've been looking for.

Be sure to check out our pins to learn more about what we have to offer. Finally, keep on checking back with our blog for even more baseball history tidbits!

Sign up to our newsletter

Get the latest articles on our news and promo discount delivered straight to your inbox

Ready to customize your pin?

Get Started

Related Posts

9 Warm Up Exercises for Kids to Practice During the Off Season

Just because they're not on the field doesn't mean your young athletes can't practice warm up drills. Here are 9 warm up exercises for kids during off season. It is no exaggeration to say that participation in sports sets children up for a lifetime of success. In addition to the physical benefits of regular exercise […]
Read this post

Teams We'Ve Worked With


Want to learn more about Baseball Trading Pins? We are always writing interesting articles about everything challenge coins! Browse our coin blog.

Baseball Trading Pins Guide

Read More

Baseball Trading Pins Guide

Read More

Baseball Trading Pins Guide

Read More
View All Resources

Limited Edition Pins Gallery

View Gallery
Back to Top